New Haven Area, Connecticut

3.4 / 2 votes

rating star
Click a star to rate this entry

Coffee shop with two vegan baked goods


Usually has vegan cupcakes made by an outside suppler, as well as pre-packaged ABC cookies.

Also serves loose-leaf teas.

Added by conde.kedar on Sep 4 10 (last updated Sep 4 10)

Edit Clone

Mark this place closed (permanently).

Most Recent Reviews

Image for Lola

rating star

I had a vegan double chocolate cupcake and a soy chai at Willoughby's. The soy chai wasn't anything special, but I was pretty excited to find a vegan cupcake at a pretty standard-looking coffee shop in downtown New Haven. The cupcake itself was nice and moist, although I found it to be a bit on the dense side. At the same time, I really liked the consistency of the chocolate frosting - it was smooth and creamy without being overly "buttery" (I hate it when vegan frostings taste like whipped Earth Balance, so Willoughby's gets points for avoiding that common pitfall).

I would give Willoughby's an extra star if they had a few more vegan desserts to choose from. It might have just been the particular day that I was visiting, but my only options seemed to be the double chocolate cupcake or Alternative Baking Company cookies. Still, I applaud Willoughby's for stocking vegan desserts in the first place. I wish that more coffee shops would follow their lead.

Image for conde.kedar

rating star

I like Willoughby's for a few reasons: 1) they carry vegan baked goods; 2) they have loose-leaf tea (make sure to ask specifically for loose-leaf, because they also have some bagged varieties); 3) they have a central location in New Haven, but manage to still exude a semblance of calmness.

The vegan cupcake they normally carry oftentimes sell out early in the week. They're pretty high quality double chocolate cupcakes made by a baker elsewhere in Connecticut. I wish they carried a few more flavors, and maybe cookies as well (yes, I know they have prepackaged ABC vegan cookies, but I'd rather have something fresh and local).

They have a respectable loose-leaf tea selection. No complaints here.

Lastly, the location is great and a quick walk to the center of the Yale campus and to major attractions such as the British Art Museum, the Yale Gallery and the New Haven Green.

Write your review


Wheelchair Accessible


  • MasterCard Visa


  • American


  • Outdoor Seating
  • Quiet
  • Wi-Fi



7am - 9pm
8am - 9pm

Edit Hours